11 Freshwater Pearl Earrings From Our Favorite Sustainable Brands
FashionGroomSpot editors endorse products we’ve personally researched, tested, and genuinely love. Learn more about our methodology and business model here.
Our editors have researched and worn dozens of sustainable jewelry brands throughout the years — these are our favorites for pearl earrings that are thoughtfully sourced with high quality materials, at a variety of price points.
Nothing says “classic” like pearls. Whether it’s a string of pearls worn around your neck, a pearl pendant dangling from a chain, or pearl studs in your ears, the organic gemstones are probably the most elegant touch you can add to any look.
And today, we’re in a bit of a pearl renaissance. Since naturally occurring pearls are exceedingly rare, and pearl farming is a thriving industry, most of our pearls are farmed, or cultured. And as far as gemstones go, pearls aren’t too expensive. The jewelry they make comes in all shapes, sizes, and styles, from understated, delicate pieces to chunky statements. These aren’t your grandmother’s pearl earrings.
Why should you consider sustainable jewelry?
When shopping for clothes or accessories, we’re always conscious of being as minimally impactful on the environment — this means consuming thoughtfully, and therefore less. And when it comes to jewelry, we like to prioritize sustainability — recycled materials, handmade goods — so we can ensure our collections are mindful and will last a lifetime.
What are the different kinds of pearls?
Not all pearls are created equal. Well, they’re all somewhat equal. They’re all produced when an irritant, like a grain of sand or a bit of shell, gets inside a mollusk, like an oyster, mussel, or clam. The mollusk then slowly covers the irritant in a substance called nacre, which, after a few years of layering and layering, becomes a pearl.
While pearls can be found in the wild, they’re super rare and therefore super expensive. Pretty much all pearls you’ll find on the market today are cultivated. Farmers introduce an irritant to a clam or mussel, place it back in the water, wait for 2 to 5 years — and finally, a pearl!
Freshwater pearls come from mussels farmed in rivers and lakes, and they’re the most common type of pearl you’ll see on the market. Saltwater pearls come from oysters, and, while they’re also cultivated, are rarer and have a shinier luster. Akoya pearls are a type of saltwater pearl — they come from the akoya oyster and are known for their perfect spherical shape. Baroque pearls refer to those with an asymmetrical shape.
How do you know that your pearl jewelry is sustainable?
Since almost all pearls are cultured, they all come from a place of sustainability since pearl farms protect the lives of mollusks, contributing to thriving mollusk populations free of harmful chemicals. The more transparent a jewelry company is about its souring, the more ethical its suppliers likely are. Plus, some mollusk species can help filter polluted water — a net benefit for the environment.
How to take care of sustainable pearl earrings:
Pearls are durable, but you should avoid banging them up or submerging them in water. Wipe them with a soft cloth every so often to remove any skin oils, and avoid getting perfume or moisturizer on them. But it’s fine to keep them in the bathroom while you’re showering — they need a bit of moisture!
Our criteria:
Our team has fallen in love with dozens of ethical and sustainable jewelry brands over the years. For this guide, we pooled together our experience, researched the best brands on the market, and scoured thousands of customer reviews for this round-up of our favorite pearl earrings that are sustainably made to last — at a variety of price points. We update this list regularly with emerging favorites that meet our criteria below.
- SUSTAINABLY SOURCED MATERIALS | Each of these sustainable jewelry brands prioritizes the use of recycled and thoughtfully sourced materials so you can feel good about where your pieces came from.
- QUALITY/DURABILITY | We’ve chosen jewelry brands that are made with high quality materials, can be worn on the daily, and will stand the test of time.
- AFFORDABLE | Jewelry — and especially sustainable jewelry — can be a big investment. We’ve included options that are more affordable while still preserving the high quality of these pieces.
In the market for other pearl pieces? Find our favorite pearl necklaces here. Looking for more ethically made jewelry? Check out our guide to sustainable jewelry.
1. Brilliant Earth
Best For | Affordable fine jewelry
Ethics & sustainability | Transparent sourcing, recycled gold & silver
Prices starting at | $125
Brilliant Earth may be known best for their customizable engagement rings. But don’t sleep on them for their other high-quality, sustainably made fine jewelry, like their line of fine cultured pearl earrings. They do all sorts of high-end styles, perfect for special occasions or gifts, from simple Ayoka pearl studs to understated, elegant drop earrings and even showstoppers like these pearl and diamond hoops, made with baroque pearls, coveted because each one has a perfectly one-of-a-kind shape. Each earring comes set in solid yellow or white gold, many of them also utilize the brand’s lab-grown diamonds, and they each come with a free lifetime warranty. Brilliant Earth is transparent about sourcing for all their gems, and they prioritize recycled and repurposed materials whenever possible — 99% of their gold and 95% of their silver is repurposed.
Customer Review | “I bought these for my mom’s 50th birthday and she absolutely loves them! I love Brilliant Earth’s values and customer service so we will continue to support Brilliant Earth over the years as we celebrate important milestones!” – Akshara (Read more reviews.)
2. John Hardy
Best For | Bali-inspired designer earrings
Ethics & sustainability | 100% recycled metals, 100% renewable energy
Prices starting at | $495
Since 1975, John Hardy has been renowned for artisan handcrafted jewelry that fuses traditional Balinese techniques with contemporary design — and their pearl earrings with timeless, Bali-inspired designs, are no exception. Each pair is crafted in their Bali workshop (made out of low-impact, native materials like bamboo and thatch!) by skilled artisans using ethically sourced freshwater pearls and 100% reclaimed gold or sterling silver — we especially love their gold pearl hoop earrings and their Surf earrings — resulting in pieces that are as sustainable as they are beautiful. In fact, less than 1% of their materials end up in landfill. The brand even partners with the Environmental Bamboo to plant bamboo seedlings in rural Indonesia, they’re a member of the Responsible Jewellery Council (RJC), and they run their production facilities with 100% renewable energy.
FashionGroomSpot Partner
3. Linjer
Best For | Delicate earrings
Ethics & sustainability | recycled solid gold and silver
Prices starting at | $89
If you’re looking for one-of-a-kind dainty pearl earring designs, look no further than Linjer’s lineup of delicate pearl earrings that strike the sweet spot between timeless and on-trend. They come in a range of fine and semi-fine styles, too — some are solid gold, while others are gold vermeil so they’re high quality without the high price tag. We love their simpler pieces like their pearl huggie earrings that are perfect for everyday wear — along with their more elevated pieces for nicer events like their pearl threader earrings or their pearl drop earrings. Linjer is all about making heirloom-quality jewelry at accessible price points, and prioritizing sustainability. All of their solid gold and sterling silver pieces are made with 100% recycled gold and silver, and their packaging is FSC certified.
Customer Review | “These pearl earrings elevate the look of my outfit everytime I wear it!! Been receiving lovely comments from family and friends on how I look prim and elegant whenever I have these on!” – Catherine S. (Read more reviews.)
4. Mejuri
Best For | On-trend semi-fine jewelry
Ethics & sustainability | recycled metals, traceable sourcing
Prices starting at | $68
One of the leaders in the sustainable jewelry industry, Mejuri has been crafting high-quality fine and semi-fine jewelry at all price points since 2015, aiming to make nice jewelry accessible to all. They’re also committed to sustainable, traceable sourcing, since luxury and sustainability go hand in hand. Their gold is made from 94% recycled gold, sterling silver from 95% recycled silver, and titanium from 100% recycled titanium. They culture their pearls from freshwater mussels, partnering with industry experts to make sure they meet quality expectations and are completely traceable. Mejuri makes two dozen styles of pearl earrings — some, like the essential pearl earrings or the oversized studs, are simple tried-and-true styles, while others, like the puffy Charlotte pearl drop earring or the dôme figure pearl hoops, are fresh and interesting. And all are timeless styles you can wear on the daily.
Customer Review | “I love Mejuri’s items! These earrings are just like other items I’ve bought from the brand, including their rings and necklaces, in terms of quality, resistance to tarnishing, and unique styling/design profile. If you have anyone who would like to add a little whimsy to their life. . . and has a reasonable yet still high amount of $$ to spend, direct them here.” – Deanna R. (Read more reviews.)
5. Aurate
Best For | Pearls with gemstones
Ethics & sustainability | recycled gold, carbon neutral
Prices starting at | $88
Aurate’s lineup of pearl earrings includes adorable huggies, drop earrings, and studs in several different sizes. Each of the freshwater cultured pearls that they use comes from a family-run farm and is AAA-rated — meaning it’s the highest quality, and never gray or dull. Most of their pearl earrings, like these pearl drop huggies, come in a few different made-to-order metal options — gold vermeil, 14K, or 18K. We especially love these emerald heirloom pearl drop earrings, made with lab-grown emeralds, and their pearl toi et moi earrings, which are all made-to-order and come with your choice of accent stone. And their pearl studs have solid gold posts and come in four different sizes for the ultimate customization. Most of the gold Aurate uses is recycled, and their products are all carbon neutral.
Customer Review | “As always, Aurate delivers a high quality product with these huggies. They’re the perfect size and work well for day time/work or a special occasion. They aren’t heavy, either, so they’re very comfortable. Love these!” – Maya B. (Read more reviews.)
6. Ana Luisa
Best For | Certified sustainable pearls
Ethics & sustainability | Climate Neutral, partnered with the Sustainable Pearl Cultivation Project
Prices starting at | $65
Ana Luisa is all about making everyday style feel elevated, and their pearl earrings are the perfect example. Whether you’re into classic pearl studs that go with literally everything or you want to try something bolder like their gold-dipped Frida huggie hoops with lustrous freshwater pearls or these dainty threader pearl earrings, there’s a design here for every vibe — think modern, vintage, or somewhere in between. And here’s a set we can’t get enough of: their mismatched Esther drop earrings. While most of their earrings are made of gold on sterling silver, making them both tarnish-resistant and affordable, they make a few (also affordable!) solid gold options, too. Ana Luisa is Climate Neutral certified, and they even partner with A Plastic Ocean Foundation on their Sustainable Pearl Cultivation project, cleaning ocean water and making ethical pearls in the meantime.
Customer Review | “I don’t usually write reviews but please don’t ever stop making these, they are the most perfect everyday earrings. they’re so comfy and the proportions of hoop to pearl are exactly right.” – Emma (Read more reviews.)
7. GLDN
Best For | Pearl earrings made in the US
Ethics & sustainability | Ethical sourcing, handmade in Washington state
Prices starting at | $44
What started as an Etsy shop is now a boom e-commerce jewelry business that effortlessly chic vibe, especially with their pearl earrings lineup. If you’re into timeless style, their pearl studs are a classic — made with genuine freshwater pearls and available in 14K gold, gold-filled, or sterling silver post options, so you can pick your favorite finish without worrying about tarnish or irritation. Want something a little more eye-catching? Check out their trinity pearl drop earrings, featuring three pearls in a cascading design that goes just as well with jeans as it does with a cocktail dress. For a softer, “everyday elegant” look, we love the pearl droplet earrings that dangle tiny pearls from dainty chains. All GLDN pieces are handcrafted in their Washington studio, and they’re big on quality and care, offering free repairs and easy returns. Plus, 10% of profits go to causes that support women and girls.
Customer Review | “I couldn’t be happier with these! I got the smaller set as I plan to mostly wear them in my second ear piercings and they are the perfect size. The packaging was nice and the handwritten note was the icing on the cake!” – Felicia J. (Read more reviews.)
8. Quince
Best For | Semi-fine earrings for less than $100
Ethics & sustainability | Recycled materials
Prices starting at | $50
Quince is one of our (new on the scene) go-tos for high-quality essentials at prices that make you do a double-take, so of course their pearl earrings are worth a spot on our list. Whether you’re into classic freshwater pearl studs with solid 14K gold posts (available in 4mm, 6mm, and 8mm sizes) or want something with a twist like their triple freshwater pearl hoops or their pearl topaz climber earrings with a modern asymmetrical design, Quince has you covered with real freshwater pearl pieces that don’t top $100. Most are crafted with 100% recycled 18K gold vermeil posts, so they’re hypoallergenic and durable. Plus, Quince is all about superior quality and transparent pricing, so you know exactly what you’re paying for. Free shipping and 365-day returns are just a bonus.
Customer Review | “These earrings are classy and super chic. I love the way they elevate an outfit and just have a timeless beautiful look. Great quality as well!” – Hanna N. (Read more reviews.)
9. Catbird
Best For | One-of-a-kind jewelry
Ethics & sustainability | Handmade in Brooklyn
Prices starting at | $44
Catbird has been handcrafting their designer (yet affordable) fine jewelry from their Brooklyn studio for over 20 years. They’ve always been meticulous about sourcing their materials and using recycled 14K gold, and while they’re known for their permanent bracelets, engagement rings, and otherwise dainty jewelry, their pearl earrings are no exception. Their collection covers everything from classic pearl studs in a pink hue — those lustrous “wear-with-everything” essentials — to one-of-a-kind pieces like these star lace ruby pearl earrings or these chime earrings with black diamonds. In fact, their pearl earring collection is dozens strong, and each pair is totally unlike anything else you’ll find on the market. Plus, Catbird’s packaging is as charming as their jewelry, making these earrings a perfect gift (even if it’s just for yourself).
Customer Review | “Like with anything from Catbird, it’s always more beautiful in person! Got these for my mom and I was blown away by how perfect they were in size and color. Very delicate, elegant, and timeless.” – Griselda R. (Read more reviews.)
10. Chan Luu
Best For | Artisan-crafted jewelry
Ethics & sustainability | Handmade pieces by fairly paid artisans around the world
Prices starting at | $65
Another brand for unique pearl earrings you won’t find anywhere else, Chan Luu delivers laid-back luxury, blending boho vibes with timeless elegance. Each pair is handcrafted and features baroque or Keshi pearls for a natural, organic feel — no two pearls of these types are exactly alike. The variety is wild: you’ll find everything from four-tiered Keshi pearl drops and delicate thread-through serpent earrings to these botanical-themed studs or dramatic cascades. Their designs play with texture and shape, mixing pearls with gold, silver, and even colorful gemstones for a look that’s both earthy and elevated. The brand was started by designer Chan Luu as a passion project in the ‘90s, and today, they’ve grown into a champion for artisan craftsmanship, partnering with artisans in Vietnam, India, Kenya, Haiti and Inner Mongolia on their handcrafted, ethically made jewelry.
11. Etsy
Best For | Variety
Ethics & sustainability | Handcrafted & vintage goods
Prices starting at | $30
Etsy is a treasure trove for all accessories (including pearl earrings), offering an incredible range of styles from artisans around the world. Whether you’re after classic freshwater pearl studs, elegant drop earrings, or trendy pearl hoops, Etsy’s marketplace has it all — and it’s easy to find customizable pieces to fit your style. You can find everything from traditional drop earring styles from Jinger Crafting to modern threaders from Hartmann Jewelry Works and funky fresh designs from Copenhagen-based @smykkeunivers. Many sellers use real, high-quality pearls paired with sterling silver, gold-filled, or 14K gold settings, ensuring both beauty and durability. You have to do a little digging to find jewelry that’s actually handmade by small businesses on Etsy — but it’s totally worth it when you can support independent creators who offer personalized touches like custom sizing or engraving.
Featured image is from Linjer
Natalie Gale is a Boston-based freelance journalist. Since 2022, she has been reviewing the top sustainable home, wellness, fashion, and beauty products, sharing her honest opinion on the best finds. When she’s not writing about art, food, or sustainability, you can find her biking to the farmers’ market, baking, sewing, or planning her next Halloween costume. Say hi on Instagram!
